Ready to Buy a Home in Montana? Here’s Why You Should Consider Renting First
Considering a move to Montana? You’re in good company, and lots of it. While the state isn’t exactly crowded, a steady stream of newcomers has kept Montana’s real estate markets popular and competitive.
Any house-hunter knows that patience pays. In a hot housing market like Montana’s, patience isn’t just wise—it’s downright necessary. Still, even new arrivals who have done their homework and waited for the opportunity that seems absolutely perfect can find that life in Montana isn’t quite what they expected.
The truth is that you can only learn so much by studying a place remotely, or even from a few brief visits. That’s why many of the happiest, most satisfied home buyers in Montana don’t buy homes at all in their first year or two—they rent. Here are three good reasons why.
The conveniences aren’t all that convenient
Montana values its wide-open spaces. That’s one of the reasons we love it so much, and one of its biggest attractions for people planning to move here. But those spaces typically mean that most things are a bit farther away than you might be used to. You may live closer to mountains, woods, and streams than ever before, while living farther away from grocery stores, pharmacists, and gas stations.
Many newcomers are surprised by how seriously this affects their daily routines. What you used to accomplish in one trip might take three in Montana. Running a few errands on your way home from work might be a habit you’ll need to leave behind. You won’t be able to fully anticipate the changes you’ll need to make and the assumptions you’ll need to abandon until you’re here, finding new ways to take care of your day-to-day needs.
By the same token, you might find that one neighborhood or town suits your style far more completely than others. Again, you won’t know until you’re here, but just knowing that you’re close to one or two especially important conveniences can help ease your transition and make you feel truly at home in Montana.
That’s a difficult proposition when you’ve already locked yourself into a mortgage in a neighborhood that doesn’t quite fit the bill. Starting out as a renter gives you the time and flexibility to find your feet as a new Montanan.
Montana weather is its own beast
For a good stretch of the year, you’ll be doing all that extra traveling in very interesting weather. Montana’s a big state, and it supports a dizzying range of microclimates. One thing they share: they can be pretty challenging in the winter.
You might not ever have put snow chains on your tires, and you might not be able to pick an engine block heater out of a lineup. Those things are standard equipment in many parts of Montana. Even urban and suburban Montanans find it important to stock up on necessities before a winter storm, and to keep plenty of candles on hand, and fresh batteries for their flashlights.
None of this is meant to worry you—people have found ways to enjoy Montana winters for thousands of years now. But like the sheer distance among things you’ll encounter in Montana, the weather will affect your routine in ways that you’ll need to experience. A year or two spent dealing with the elements—and sharing stories with your neighbors—will give you a much better sense of how to make the most of our ever-changing weather.
You might find that you really enjoy the change of seasons, and that you’d prefer a more remote location. You might find yourself dealing with the elements a bit too far from town. Renting lets you refine your idea of how to make a happy peace with Montana’s weather, and to put yourself in the best possible place. A mortgage means that you tackle the weather on Mother Nature’s terms.
You need time and connections to negotiate a real estate market this hot
Newly arrived Montanans have been dealing with long trips and capricious weather since before there was a Montana. That won’t change any time soon. The real estate sector, though, is constantly evolving. And we’re in the midst of a doozy of a seller’s market.
Prospective homebuyers don’t hold many cards in Montana these days. Buyers from out of state are at an even greater disadvantage when it comes to identifying the best opportunities, making convincing offers, and closing deals on comfortable terms. Establishing yourself as a renter can give you an obvious edge or two and can help in ways you might not have considered.
From a distance, you’ll be able to scour MLS listings. You might even have struck up a relationship with a real estate agent in Montana. But actually, living in a place is your best early-alert system for new home-buying opportunities. You might even hear of properties that are about to hit the market, before any of your friends back home do. When you’re quicker to make offers, some sellers are quicker to say yes.
You might even enjoy an important strategic advantage while sellers weigh competing offers. Each seller is different, but your local presence in Montana—the fact that you’ve committed yourself to building a life here—might just make your offer stand out from ones made by out-of-staters. The right seller might even be inclined to leave a few dollars on the table if it means passing their home along to someone with local roots, even if those roots only started growing a year or two ago.
Montana is different. That’s why we love it. It’s also why you should consider getting your feet wet before buying a home here. Renting your first Montana home is a smart way to make your money and your time work in your favor.





